Arkhaven logo

39 A Contempt Citation panel 1

Episode 39: A Contempt Citation


“If the defense has concluded presenting its case,” Judge Connor continued, “we can move on to closing statements.”


“Your honor,” Senator Travis rose, legal pad in hand, “if it please the court, there is still the matter of the additional affidavits and evidence we filed last night which your honor has agreed to review with an open mind to reconsider whether we should have an opportunity to lay that evidence before the jury.”

39 A Contempt Citation panel 3

“Your honor,” Senator Castillo rose. “We respectfully request the opportunity to cross-examine these supposed experts and have that cross-examination entered into the record as well.”


“You would only have that opportunity,” the judge answered, “if I allowed the witnesses to testify on the stand.”


“Unless those witnesses’ testimony is to be placed before the jury,” Senator Travis observed, “they have no right to cross-examination. If we are not allowed to present our evidence and proof to the jury in open court, then we want to submit it in the record for the appellate court.”


“Professor,” Judge Connor asked, “what is the purpose of cross-examination?”


The purpose of cross-examination,” Senator Travis replied, “is to enlighten the jury in trial in open court.”


“Isn’t it an effort to ascertain the truth?” the judge asked.


“In this case,” a testy Senator Travis replied, “it’s an effort to show prejudice.”


“Order!” The judge banged his gavel to silence the titters of laughter that erupted in the courtroom.


“Your honor has denied the defense the opportunity to put our expert witnesses on record in front of the jury,” Senator Travis pointed out. “We merely wish to enter into the record the evidence you insist on keeping from the jury: not only the testimony of Dr. Lachman, but also the testimony of some of the de-transitioned victims of this gender affirmation mania. The state’s theory is that none of that evidence is relevant, and you have – so far – excluded that evidence as the state requested. The purpose of allowing the evidence into the record is that the higher court might properly determine whether this court was in error to exclude the evidence, whereupon your honor’s decision would either be upheld, or the case would be sent back with the instruction that the evidence be presented. Only in that latter case would the state be entitled to cross-examination.”


“I understood, your honor,” Senator Castillo interjected, “that we would have the right to cross-examine any of their supposed experts whether or not they were presented before the jury.”


“This court rules,” Judge Connor decided, “that the state and defense may both submit to the record of this case what affidavits and evidence they wish, but that none of the additional evidence in question that the defense has offered thus far will be presented before the jury. The court finds it inflammatory, prejudicial, and representing fringe viewpoints not generally accepted by the scientific and medical communities.”

39 A Contempt Citation panel 5

“I take exception to your honor’s ruling,” Senator Travis slapped his legal pad down on the defense table to emphasize the point. “This is hardly the fair and open reading of the evidence and affidavits your honor led us to expect.”


“I hope,” Judge Connor said dryly, “that the counsel for the defense intends no reflection upon this court.”


“Your honor is entitled to hope,” Senator Travis replied.


“I have the right to more than just hope,” Judge Connor’s brow furrowed in anger.


“As do I, your honor,” Senator Travis replied, “But sadly, my hopes have also been dashed.”

39 A Contempt Citation panel 7

“Your attitude is unacceptable,” Judge Connor glowered at Senator Travis, “and this court demands an apology.”


“Your honor may continue to hope,” Senator Travis sat down.


“I find you in contempt of court. BAILIFF!” Judge Connor spoke sternly. “Detain Senator Travis overnight, and we’ll see if his attitude improves. This court stands adjourned until 9am tomorrow morning.”


“All rise!” Deputy Martínez announced.


As the judge departed, Senator Castillo proclaimed to the throng, “Everyone! We’re having an ‘End the Hate’ rally on the courthouse steps in two hours. See you all there!”


She turned to Senator Travis. “So sorry you’re going to miss it,” she smirked. Then, she turned her back to him and departed with Tony, President Buchmann, and Acey trailing behind.


“Sorry, Senator,” Deputy Martínez said, “but I’m going to have to ask you to accompany me.”

39 A Contempt Citation panel 9
39 A Contempt Citation panel 10
The Wise of Heart series cover
39 A Contempt Citation episode cover
34K views1.4K likes
75 comments

The Wise of Heart

Created by
author avatar
Aetherczar
He wanted to test the new Gender Awareness in Academia (GAIA) Act, but high-school biology teacher, Mike Andrews, got more than he bargained for. Arrested and thrown in jail for the crime of teaching the biology of sex determination and for refusing to affirm a student’s gender identity, Mike faces a show trial amid a media circus. The Wise of Heart offers a timely tale of transgender mania as author Hans G. Schantz re-imagines and updates the story of the Scopes Monkey Trial.
57 Coda episode cover
57 CodaEpisode #57
56 A Silent Contemplation episode cover
56 A Silent ContemplationEpisode #56
55 A Final Farewell episode cover
55 A Final FarewellEpisode #55
54 Hit the Road episode cover
54 Hit the RoadEpisode #54
53 Senator Castillo’s Big Announcement episode cover
53 Senator Castillo’s Big AnnouncementEpisode #53
52 The Superintendent's Reward episode cover
52 The Superintendent's RewardEpisode #52
51 Strike the Tent episode cover
51 Strike the TentEpisode #51
50 An Unexpected Proposal episode cover
50 An Unexpected ProposalEpisode #50
49 A Premature Conclusion episode cover
49 A Premature ConclusionEpisode #49
48 A Summons for the Superintendent episode cover
48 A Summons for the SuperintendentEpisode #48
47 I Have Your Back episode cover
47 I Have Your BackEpisode #47
46 A Surprise Witness for the Defense episode cover
46 A Surprise Witness for the DefenseEpisode #46
45 A Cowboy Speeding Ticket episode cover
45 A Cowboy Speeding TicketEpisode #45
44 An Unexpected Proposition episode cover
44 An Unexpected PropositionEpisode #44
43 Trust the Spin Doctors episode cover
43 Trust the Spin DoctorsEpisode #43
42 The Aftermath episode cover
42 The AftermathEpisode #42
41 The "End-Hate" Rally episode cover
41 The "End-Hate" RallyEpisode #41
40 Acey's Reaction episode cover
40 Acey's ReactionEpisode #40
39 A Contempt Citation episode cover
39 A Contempt CitationEpisode #39
38 Castillo Cross-Examines Mike episode cover
38 Castillo Cross-Examines MikeEpisode #38
37 Mike Andrews Testifies episode cover
37 Mike Andrews TestifiesEpisode #37
36 The Judge Rules on the Defense Testimony  episode cover
36 The Judge Rules on the Defense Testimony Episode #36
35 Putting the Transphobia in the Andrews Transphobia Trial episode cover
35 Putting the Transphobia in the Andrews Transphobia TrialEpisode #35
34 Travis and Castillo Confer episode cover
34 Travis and Castillo ConferEpisode #34
33  Castillo Cross-Examines Dr. Lachman episode cover
33 Castillo Cross-Examines Dr. LachmanEpisode #33
32-Dr. Lachman Testifies episode cover
32-Dr. Lachman TestifiesEpisode #32
31-The Judge Rules on Expert Testimony episode cover
31-The Judge Rules on Expert TestimonyEpisode #31
30 An Empathetic Nudge episode cover
30 An Empathetic NudgeEpisode #30
29  A Final Appeal episode cover
29 A Final AppealEpisode #29
28 All That Nonsense episode cover
28 All That NonsenseEpisode #28
27 Senator Castillo Objects episode cover
27 Senator Castillo ObjectsEpisode #27
26 Harry Shelton Testifies episode cover
26 Harry Shelton TestifiesEpisode #26
25 Clowns and Ringmasters episode cover
25 Clowns and RingmastersEpisode #25
24 A Private Lunch episode cover
24 A Private LunchEpisode #24
23 Best Two Out of Three episode cover
23 Best Two Out of ThreeEpisode #23
22 Senator Travis Cross-Examines President Buchmann episode cover
22 Senator Travis Cross-Examines President BuchmannEpisode #22
21 President Buchmann Testifies episode cover
21 President Buchmann TestifiesEpisode #21
20 A Plethora of Propagandists episode cover
20 A Plethora of PropagandistsEpisode #20
19 An Offer He Can't Refuse episode cover
19 An Offer He Can't RefuseEpisode #19
18 A Disgruntled Superintendent episode cover
18 A Disgruntled SuperintendentEpisode #18
17 Sue Morgan Testifies episode cover
17 Sue Morgan TestifiesEpisode #17
16 The Superintendent Testifies episode cover
16 The Superintendent TestifiesEpisode #16
15 The Defense Reveals Their Case episode cover
15 The Defense Reveals Their CaseEpisode #15
14 Ruling on the Motion to Quash episode cover
14 Ruling on the Motion to QuashEpisode #14
13 An Unauthorized Disclosure episode cover
13 An Unauthorized DisclosureEpisode #13
12 Clowns & Ringmasters episode cover
12 Clowns & RingmastersEpisode #12
11 The Defense Argument episode cover
11 The Defense ArgumentEpisode #11
10 The State's Rebuttal episode cover
10 The State's RebuttalEpisode #10
09 A Motion to Quash episode cover
09 A Motion to QuashEpisode #9
08 The Show Begins episode cover
08 The Show BeginsEpisode #8
07 A Private Moment episode cover
07 A Private MomentEpisode #7
06 Jury Selection episode cover
06 Jury SelectionEpisode #6
05 You May Be Seated - The Media Circus episode cover
05 You May Be Seated - The Media CircusEpisode #5
04 Welcome to the Big Top episode cover
04 Welcome to the Big TopEpisode #4
03 Pitching the Tent episode cover
03 Pitching the TentEpisode #3
02 An Educational Misdemeanor episode cover
02 An Educational MisdemeanorEpisode #2
01 Introduction and A Conspiracy is Born episode cover
01 Introduction and A Conspiracy is BornEpisode #1
,
List icon
Comment icon
Prev icon
Next icon
Fullscreen icon